Rahmat Wibowo Infraloka asked whether AWS runs the WhatsApp group that removed him

He published a timeline of his removal from the Kiro User Group Indonesia WhatsApp groups under AWS Indonesia's name, asking whether the company runs the community while conceding that many product communities are run by enthusiasts and that his questions 'may have been misdirected'.

Original post ↗

Rahmat Wibowo Infraloka asked whether AWS runs the WhatsApp group that removed him

Commentary

What he posted

He published it on InfraLoka’s blog on 14 November 2026 under “Professional Blacklist”, titled “Kiro User Group Indonesia WhatsApp Removal, 13 November 2026: Timeline and the Question of Who Runs the Community” and tagged “Amazon Web Services” and “AWS Indonesia”. He writes: “This article does not claim that AWS Indonesia owns, funds or controls the community. I do not know.” His timeline shows that at 12.35 he forwarded “a screenshot of my own quiz admin page to the group with a short caption”, and that at 12.45 the administrator “removed you” on both “Kiro User Group Indonesia” and “General”. He argues that when “a company-linked community” removes a member, “readers may expect a code of conduct, an appeal route and a named responsible person”, and that he asked in writing whether the community is “managed, supported or known to the company”. Under “What I cannot say” he lists “That the removal was unfair”, referring to his caveat that “my screenshot showed another person’s data”. He adds: “Many product communities are run by enthusiasts and employees in their own time, with no company role. If that is the case here, my questions to the company may have been misdirected”.

Context

The same day he published a page on the same removal under Purnaresa Yuliartanto’s name (ev-20261114-012) and the terms of his legal notice 053 to AWS Indonesia, Anthony Amni and Purnaresa (ev-20261114-011). On 13 November he called Purnaresa a “hypocrite” on Threads (ev-20261113-005) and blamed AWS Indonesia staff for his removal from community groups (ev-20261113-006).

Observations

A company’s name on a page about a chat group

He tags the page “Amazon Web Services” and “AWS Indonesia” while stating it does not claim the company owns, funds or controls the community. The only links he shows are the product the group discusses and the employer of its administrator. The company’s name is placed beside a grievance it is not shown to have any part in.

A third page on one ten-minute removal

This is his third page that day on the same removal, after the page under Purnaresa Yuliartanto’s name and the legal notice page (ev-20261114-012, ev-20261114-011). Each repeats the 12.35 post and the 12.45 removal. Spreading one incident across several pages multiplies the search results tied to the names involved.

Conceding his questions to AWS may be misdirected

He writes that many product communities are run by volunteers “with no company role” and that his questions “may have been misdirected”. He had already put them to the company in a formal legal notice with a deadline (ev-20261114-011). The concession comes after the demand, not before it.

Transcript

Home / Professional Blacklist / Kiro User Group Indonesia WhatsApp Removal, 13 November 2026: Timeline and the Question of Who Runs the Community Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation Professional Blacklist Amazon Web Services A W S Indonesia Kiro User Group Indonesia Kiro User Group Indonesia WhatsApp Removal, 13 November 2026: Timeline and the Question of Who Runs the Community Rahmat Wibowo · November 14, 2026 Is a WhatsApp group for Kiro users in Indonesia a private chat, a community of a product made by Amazon Web Services, or something in between? The answer decides whose rules apply when a member is removed. I do not know it, and this post sets out why I asked. This article does not claim that AWS Indonesia owns, funds or controls the community. I do not know. It is a timeline plus an open question. This is my account and my opinion. It is not a finding by any court or regulator. Scope and identity note The community: two WhatsApp groups called "Kiro User Group Indonesia" (announcements) and "General" (discussion). I was a member of both. Kiro: the product around which the groups are built. I treat it here only as the topic of the groups. People: I name only the administrator shown by the app. Details are in the record on Purnaresa Yuliartanto. Timeline Time, 13 November 2026 What the screens show 12.35 I forward a screenshot of my own quiz admin page to the group with a short caption 12.45 System line: the administrator "removed you", on "Kiro User Group Indonesia" 12.45 The same line on "General" After I can read neither group's messages nor post in them Why I ask who runs it When a private group removes a member, the usual answer is that the owner may do as they like. When a company-linked community does it, readers may expect a code of conduct, an appeal route and a named responsible person. I could find none of these in what I saw. So I asked, in writing, whether the community is managed, supported or known to the company, and what the administrator's position in it is. What I cannot say Who owns the groups. The app shows administrators, not owners. That the groups have, or lack, written rules. I saw none, which is not the same as none existing. That the company knew about the removal. That the removal was unfair. See my own caveat in the person record: my screenshot showed another person's data. Where I am probably wrong Many product communities are run by enthusiasts and employees in their own time, with no company role. If that is the case here, my questions to the company may have been misdirected, and I will say so. What would settle it A one-paragraph statement of who manages the groups, what the rules are and how to appeal. That costs little and would end the guessing for every member. Right of reply and correction policy PT Amazon Web Services Indonesia and the administrators of the groups are invited to send a response, correction or added context. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change. Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id #ProfessionalBlacklist #AmazonWebServices #AWSIndonesia #KiroUserGroupIndonesia #RightOfReply