Rahmat Wibowo sorted Rama Abdurachman's reply into fair criticism and insult
He published a page accepting that criticism of his 'somasi as a service', and the point that he is 'Not a law firm, not a notary', are fair, while disputing slurs such as 'Stupid EQ' and 'loser in life', and agreeing that a reader who finds his legal response out of proportion holds 'a fair view'.
| ID | ev-20261110-010 |
|---|---|
| Source | Infraloka Blog |
| Modus operandi | Legal Threats and Extortion Hypocrisy |
| Targets | Rama Abdurachman |

Transcript
Home / Professional Blacklist / "Somasi as a Service": Criticism Is Fair, Insult Is Not Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation Professional Blacklist Rama Abdurachman Somasi Right Of Reply "Somasi as a Service": Criticism Is Fair, Insult Is Not Rahmat Wibowo · November 10, 2026 A public reply by Rama Abdurachman mocked "somasi as a service". Some of it is a fair opinion about my practice. Some of it is not. This post separates the two, because I want a legal notice to hit only the second part. This article does not claim that every sentence in the reply is unlawful. It says which sentences I accept as criticism and which I dispute. The full record is in the main post. This is my account and my opinion. It is not a finding by any court. What I accept Criticism of somasi as a practice. A somasi is a written warning. People can think a person who sends many of them is a nuisance. That is an opinion on a public matter. "Not a law firm, not a notary, no PKPA." Accurate. I act for myself as the aggrieved party, which is every citizen's right, and I do not present myself as a law firm. My own letter says I am not one. A blunt tone. Public threads are rough. I do not ask anyone to be polite. What I dispute Slurs aimed at me, not at the argument. "Stupid EQ", "loser in life" and an expletive say nothing about whether a somasi is right or wrong. References to my health. A phrase meaning "mentally defective" and an instruction to "take your medications" are not about somasi. I explain why in a separate post. A claim of fact about the police. The reply says an investigator laughed and sent me home. That is a statement about what happened, not an opinion. See the police-report post. A simple test If you can delete the person and keep the sentence, it is probably criticism: "somasi letters sent in bulk waste police time". If the sentence only works with the person in it, it is closer to an insult: "he is a loser who needs medication". The second kind says nothing a reader can check. What I cannot say That the reply is criminal. In my letter I say it fits certain articles of the 2023 Criminal Code. That is my argument, not a finding. That "it was a joke" is no defence. It may be one, and a court will decide. That he meant the health remarks about me. I argue he did, because the reply says "take your medications". Where I am probably wrong I am sensitive on this topic and may judge it harshly. A reader may think the legal response is out of proportion to a thread reply. That is a fair view and I have kept the door open to a settlement. Right of reply and correction policy Rama Abdurachman is invited to send a response, correction or added context. A substantive response may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it promptly and note the change. Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id #ProfessionalBlacklist #RamaAbdurachman #Somasi #RightOfReply
Commentary
What he posted
He published it on InfraLoka’s blog on 10 November 2026 under “Professional Blacklist”, titled “‘Somasi as a Service’: Criticism Is Fair, Insult Is Not”. He writes: “A public reply by Rama Abdurachman mocked ‘somasi as a service’. Some of it is a fair opinion about my practice. Some of it is not.” Under “What I accept” he lists “Criticism of somasi as a practice”, the line “‘Not a law firm, not a notary, no PKPA.’ Accurate.”, and “A blunt tone. Public threads are rough. I do not ask anyone to be polite.” Under “What I dispute” he lists “‘Stupid EQ’, ’loser in life’ and an expletive” and the line about the police. He offers a test: “If you can delete the person and keep the sentence, it is probably criticism”, while a sentence that “only works with the person in it” is “closer to an insult”. He ends: “I am sensitive on this topic and may judge it harshly. A reader may think the legal response is out of proportion to a thread reply. That is a fair view and I have kept the door open to a settlement.”
Context
The legal response is legal notice 093, demanding Rp533,333,333.34, whose deadlines he published the same day (ev-20261110-009). That morning Rama Abdurachman apologised and withdrew the words (doc-20261110-005), and Rahmat replied that the apology counted only as half because Rama declined to pay (doc-20261110-004). He named Rama in at least eight posts that day (ev-20261110-002).
Observations
Half the reply accepted, the full demand kept
He accepts that criticism of his somasi practice is fair, that “Not a law firm, not a notary, no PKPA” is “Accurate”, and that a blunt tone is acceptable. His notice still demands Rp533 million over the reply as a whole (doc-20261110-003). Conceding part of the reply did not reduce what he asked for.
Calling disproportion “a fair view” and changing nothing
He writes that a reader may think the legal response is out of proportion, and that “That is a fair view”. The same day, after Rama Abdurachman apologised and withdrew the words, he counted the apology as only half because Rama declined to pay (doc-20261110-004). The door he says is open to settlement has a price on it.
His own test, applied to his own posts
His test treats a sentence that “only works with the person in it” as closer to an insult. That day he named Rama Abdurachman in at least eight posts and brought up the child Rama had in September (ev-20261110-002). Remarks like that only work with Rama in them.