Rahmat Wibowo listed what Marchel Shevchenko must show to prove an MIT research link

He ranked five kinds of document, from written confirmation by MIT to a lab's acknowledgement, that would back Marchel Andrian Shevchenko's 'Research Student @mit', invited Marchel to send them for publication, and called the page 'a methods piece' filed under 'Professional Blacklist'.

Original post ↗

Rahmat Wibowo listed what Marchel Shevchenko must show to prove an MIT research link

Commentary

What he posted

He published it on InfraLoka’s blog on 8 November 2026 under “Professional Blacklist”, titled “Marchel Andrian Shevchenko’s ‘Research Student at MIT’: What Would Count as Proof”. He writes: “This is a methods piece. It does not conclude that the claim is false, and it does not conclude that it is true.” He explains that “‘Research Student’ is a loose phrase, not a degree” and ranks five kinds of proof, from “Written confirmation from MIT” to “A public acknowledgement from a lab or faculty member”. He writes that only “a written statement from the institution that no such relationship exists” would count against the claim, and that “I have not obtained one and do not claim to.” He says his own search “is small, so it is not evidence of absence”, and invites Marchel “to send any of the documents above”, which “may be published alongside this article”.

Context

He has tagged MIT about Marchel (ev-20261104-003) and earlier warned Singapore about Marchel (ev-20260608-003). In June he announced that his own company had found Marchel guilty of credential fraud (ev-20260601-007). The same day as this page he published Marchel’s claims against public records and a table of Data Sorcerers’ claims (ev-20261108-019, ev-20261108-021).

Observations

The burden of proof put on Marchel

The page sets out what Marchel would have to produce, and invites Marchel to send it so that it “may be published alongside this article”. Only the institution’s written denial would count against the claim, and he has “not obtained one”. A young person is asked to prove an affiliation in public, on a page under Marchel’s own name.

A small search, a wide campaign

He writes that his search “is small, so it is not evidence of absence”. The campaign around it is not small: he has tagged MIT and the organisers of Marchel’s talk and warned Singapore about Marchel (ev-20261104-003, ev-20260608-003). The reach of the accusations is far wider than the search behind them.

A methods piece filed under Professional Blacklist

He calls the page “a methods piece” that “does not conclude that the claim is false”. It is still filed under “Professional Blacklist”, with Marchel’s full name in the title. Anyone searching Marchel’s name meets the blacklist label before the disclaimer.

Transcript

Home / Professional Blacklist / Marchel Andrian Shevchenko's "Research Student at MIT": What Would Count as Proof Professional Blacklist: personal dispute documentation Professional Blacklist Credential Verification M I T Claims Vs Record Marchel Andrian Shevchenko's "Research Student at MIT": What Would Count as Proof Rahmat Wibowo · November 8, 2026 A title like "Research Student" can mean many things. This article asks what documents would settle what it means in one public profile, instead of arguing from screenshots. This is a methods piece. It does not conclude that the claim is false, and it does not conclude that it is true. Scope and identity note The profile belongs to Marchel Andrian Shevchenko, speaker at a Telkom AI Center of Excellence event on 8 November 2026. His LinkedIn education section lists "Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Research Student, Computer Science, Sep 2024 – Present", and his Instagram bio reads "Research Student @mit". The national higher-education database entry I captured lists him as an undergraduate at Universitas Teknologi Yogyakarta. These are screenshots from around 29 August 2026 and are not authenticated. See the side-by-side. Why the two entries are not automatically in conflict An undergraduate elsewhere can do research with an MIT lab, through a volunteer arrangement, an online programme, a visiting scheme or a collaboration. "Research Student" is a loose phrase, not a degree. So the useful question is not "is he a PhD student" (his own "About" text says he is finishing an undergraduate degree), but "what is the actual relationship, and does the title describe it fairly". What would count as proof Ranked from strongest to weakest: Written confirmation from MIT (a department, lab or programme office) stating the nature and dates of the relationship. A letter from a named supervisor at MIT, on institutional letterhead, with a way to verify it. A programme record, such as acceptance into a named visiting or online research programme. Research output: a paper, preprint or repository showing the speaker as an author or contributor alongside MIT-affiliated researchers. A public acknowledgement from a lab or faculty member. A profile, a bio or a third party's repeating of the title are not proof of the relationship. What would count against it Not finding items 1 to 5 does not count against it. Only a written statement from the institution that no such relationship exists would. I have not obtained one and do not claim to. What I found I have not found any item in the list above. That is limited to my own search, which is small, so it is not evidence of absence. Where I may be wrong The relationship may exist in a form that leaves no public trace. I may have missed a paper or acknowledgement. The title may be a loose but honest description. What I asked for I asked the Telkom Integrity Line to verify the claim from primary sources, which is the only route that gives an answer. See what I asked Telkom to do. Right of reply and correction policy Marchel Andrian Shevchenko is invited to send any of the documents above, or a response. Documents may be published alongside this article, subject to reasonable editing for privacy, safety and relevance. If reliable evidence shows that any factual statement here is wrong, I will correct it and note the change. Published by Rahmat Wibowo, InfraLoka — infraloka.co.id #ProfessionalBlacklist #CredentialVerification #MIT #ClaimsVsRecord