‘& Rahmat Wibowo as
aw
Your professional review is legally protected.
Here is what most people do not know.
Indonesia's Constitutional Court (MK Ruling
No. 105/PUU-XxIl/2024, April 2025) made a
landmark decision that changes everything
for professionals speaking up online.
The phrase "orang lain" in Pasal 27A UU No.
1 Tahun 2024 applies ONLY to private
individuals. Professions, positions,
corporations, and institutions are explicitly
excluded as defamation victims under UU
ITE.
What this means in practice: if you review
someone's performance as an HRBP,
Director, or any professional role, you are
evaluating the position, not attacking the
person. That distinction is legally significant.
The SKB UU ITE also confirms: content that
constitutes an assessment, opinion,
evaluation, or factual statement cannot be
categorized as criminal defamation,
The line is clear:
Documenting that an HRBP like Dinda
Rhapsodya from Liven created a hostile
work environment:
protected
Evaluating a Director's leadership failures
with evidence:
protected
Fabricating facts or making personal attacks
unrelated to the role: not protected
The law was never designed to shield poor
professional performance from scrutiny.
It exists to protect personal honor, not
positional authority.
Know your rights.
Write on the right side of the line.
#IndonesianLaw #UUITE #HukumDigital
#FreeSpeech #ProfessionalRights
#HRBPAccountability
#Mahkamahkonstitusi
#KebebasanBerekspresi
#WorkplaceAccountability
#Linkedinindonesia #LegalLiteracy
#infraloka
Commentary
What he posted
He posted it on LinkedIn around 26 June 2026 under “Your professional review is legally protected”. Citing Constitutional Court ruling 105/PUU-XXII/2024, he argued that reviewing someone’s performance “as an HRBP, Director, or any professional role” means “evaluating the position, not attacking the person”, and so is not defamation. His first example was “Documenting that an HRBP like Dinda Rhapsodya from Liven created a hostile work environment: protected”.
Context
Dinda Rhapsodya had complained about his behaviour towards Liven staff (ev-20260603-001). The next day he posted that he suspected she had bribed the police (ev-20260627-005).
Observations
A legal explainer built around one woman’s name
The post reads as general advice, but its main example names Dinda and asserts, as fact, that she created a hostile work environment. The explainer is a vehicle for the accusation. Readers learn her name and the charge, not the law.
A role, not a person, then personal accusations
He says criticism of a role is protected because it is not personal. His other posts about Dinda accuse her of lying, hypocrisy and bribery (ev-20260627-005). Those are claims about the person, which by his own line are not protected.