Rahmat Wibowo released an AI-written defence memorial for Nadiem Makarim

He announced his public release of an AI-generated legal defense memorial for Nadiem Makarim, confidently asserting substantial reasonable doubt and recommending acquittal while overstating his engine's authoritative legal conclusions.

Original post ↗

Rahmat Wibowo released an AI-written defence memorial for Nadiem Makarim

Commentary

What he posted

He posted it on LinkedIn around 20 June 2026: “Today, I publicly released a Legal Defense Memorial for Nadiem Makarim, prepared by InfraLoka Legal Intelligence using our AEGIS Defense research engine.” He listed findings for the former minister’s Chromebook procurement corruption case, including that “a flawed policy is not automatically a criminal act”, gave “overall defense confidence: 8/10” and recommended acquittal. He invoked “in dubio pro reo”, the principle that unresolved doubt should favour the accused, said he does not know Nadiem personally, and tagged the law firm Assegaf Hamzah & Partners, Ahmad Fikri Assegaf, PERADI and Otto Hasibuan.

Context

Ibrahim Arief is a defendant in the same Chromebook procurement case. In the same weeks Rahmat made Ibrahim the subject of a “field guide to manufactured innocence” and sent him a legal notice demanding Rp2 billion (ev-20260728-012, ev-20260728-003).

Observations

Reasonable doubt for one defendant, none for another

He asks the court to give Nadiem the benefit of the doubt. For Ibrahim Arief, in the same case, he demands that the accused “demonstrate evidence of proper conduct” (ev-20260728-003). The principle he invokes depends on who the defendant is.

Unsolicited advice tagged to lawyers and the bar

Nothing shows anyone asked for the memorial. Tagging a law firm, PERADI and senior advocates puts InfraLoka’s name beside one of the country’s best-known trials. The memorial works as publicity for his “engine”.

Transcript

Today, I publicly released a Legal Defense Memorial for Nadiem Makarim, prepared by InfraLoka Legal Intelligence using our AEGIS Defense research engine. After reviewing the case analysis, verifying the legal references, and testing the prosecution's strongest arguments against the defense, my conclusion is that there is substantial reasonable doubt. Key findings: + No direct evidence links Google's investment in PT AKAB to the Chromebook procurement policy. The required causal chain for criminal intent has not been proven. + A flawed policy is not automatically a criminal act. Supreme Court precedent distinguishes policy mistakes from corruption. + The prosecution's Rp 5.6 trillion compensation demand is significantly higher than the alleged Rp 2.1 trillion state loss, creating a serious legal inconsistency. + Conflict of interest is primarily an administrative issue under Indonesian law and does not automatically establish criminal intent. + The legal review itself estimated a 25% probability of acquittal, an unusually high figure for a corruption case. Under the principle of in dubio pro reo, unresolved doubt should favor the defendant. Overall defense confidence: 8/10. Recommended outcome: Acquittal (Vrijspraak) I do not know Nadiem Makarim personally and have no political affiliation. My position is based solely on legal analysis and the principle that criminal guilt must be proven beyond reasonable doubt. Justice must apply equally to everyone, not only to those with influence or resources. Assegaf Hamzah & Partners PERADI Perhimpunan Advokat Indonesia (PERADI) DPN PERADI Ahmad Fikri Assegaf Otto Hasibuan #NadiemMakarim #inDubioProReo #Tipikor #RuleOfLaw #LegalDefense #JusticeForAll #infraLoka #Vrijspraak