Rahmat Wibowo posted a detailed engineering assessment rating Graciella Valeska Liander 3.1/10 and declaring her 'not eligible' for a full-time associate role, citing critical deficiencies in a post that publicly disparages and defames a named individual.

20h - Edited Engineering Assessment Summary ‘Smart Waste Management System (SWMS) Graciella Valeska Liander Evaluator: Principal Software Engineer (Google Standards) Repository: STATUS: NOT ELIGIBLE FOR FULL-TIME ASSOCIATE ROLE Overall Rating: 3.1/10 Quick Breakdown SDLC Maturity: 3.5/10 CI/CD: 2/10 (CRITICAL - No automation) Code Quality: 4/10 Architecture: 5/10 Testing: 2/10 (CRITICAL - Zero coverage) Security: 2/10 (CRITICAL - Exposed keys) Documentation: 3/10 Executive Summary Graciella delivered a functional loT dashboard with real-time React + Firebase visualization. The app works end-to-end and shows good modern web skills. However, it lacks the testing, Ci/CD, security, and operational maturity required for production or full-time Associate Engineer roles at Google/AWS standards. Key Strengths End-to-end working application Responsive mobile-first UI Real-time Firebase integration Clean git commits Critical Deficiencies Zero test coverage No CI/CD pipeline Hardcoded Firebase secrets in public repo Monolithic 216-line component No error handling or monitoring Must-Fix Issues EXPOSED SECRETS - Firebase keys public in firebase.js. Regenerate and use .env immediately. ZERO TESTS ~ Only failing placeholder. Need >80% coverage. NO CI/CD ~ All manual deployments. MONOLITHIC CODE ~ Needs modular refactoring. This review is shared as a constructive growth tool for early-career engineers building production-ready systems. What are your thoughts on entry-level expectations in tech hiring? Serene Sia Graciela Valeska Liander Sundar Pichai Thomas Kurian Veronica U. #SoftwareEngineering #CodeReview #TechHiring #ReactJS #Firebase #CI_CD #SoftwareTesting #CyberSecurity #CareerDevelopment #JuniorDeveloper #DevOps #TechMentorship