He posted a "Hiring Manager Summary" rating Rahmat Fabhian Aminuddin's personal "CV Checker project" 3.2/10 against an "AWS Principal Engineer Level" standard with the recommendation "DO NOT HIRE for Solutions Architect Role", and tagged AWS leaders.
Commentary
What he posted
He posted it on LinkedIn at about 03:30 WIB on 28 May 2026. It presents a “Hiring Manager Summary” with “Candidate: Rahmat Fabhian Aminuddin”, “Assessment Standard: AWS Principal Engineer Level”, “Overall Rating: 3.2/10” and “Recommendation: DO NOT HIRE for Solutions Architect Role”, based on “Rahmat’s CV Checker project”, with scores such as “Testing & Quality Assurance: 0/10”. He tagged AWS, Andy Jassy, Matt Garman, Jeff Johnson, Hussein Mohd Ali and Huajia Ma. A commenter replied: “ini bukannya cuma personal project? dan juga udah lama, maybe masih dalam tahap belajar?” (“isn’t this just a personal project? and an old one too, maybe still at the learning stage?”)
Context
Forty minutes later he posted a second assessment of the same man with a different score, 4.2/10 (ev-20260527-009). He merged both into a “3.2-4.2/10” range in his “case study” the next day (ev-20260528-002).
Observations
A side project graded as a job application
The evaluation is of a “CV Checker project”, which a commenter points out is an old personal project. He grades it for testing, monitoring and CI/CD as if it were a production system. Few learning projects would pass that test.
A principal-level bar for a different role
He measures a candidate for a Solutions Architect role against an “AWS Principal Engineer Level” standard. That is a senior engineering level, not the role he names. Setting the bar there guarantees the low score.
No vacancy, yet a hiring verdict
No employer has asked for this evaluation and no vacancy is named. The recommendation “DO NOT HIRE” is addressed to anyone who might hire the man, and AWS’s leaders are tagged. The format of a hiring report is used to warn people off him.
Transcript
Hiring Manager Summary ~ Solutions
Architect Role Evaluation
Candidate: Rahmat Fabhian Aminuddin
Role Evaluated: Solutions Architect
Assessment Standard: AWS Principal
Engineer Level
Overall Rating: 3.2/10
Recommendation:
DO NOT HIRE for Solutions Architect Role
Executive Summary
Rahmat's CV Checker project was assessed
against real-world Solutions Architect
standards — the kind of role that requires
designing mission-critical cloud
architectures and advising CTOs and senior
executives.
While he shows foundational AWS knowledge
and the ability to deliver end-to-end
features, the evaluation revealed critical gaps
in testing, security, monitoring, operational
readiness, and architectural decision-
making.
These gaps would pose a significant risk to
customer success and technical standards if
placed in a Solutions Architect position.
However, with proper mentorship, he has the
potential to grow in a junior or mid-level
engineering role.
The Rating Breakdown (3.2/10):
Testing & Quality Assurance: 0/10 (zero
tests, zero test infrastructure)
Security Practices: 2/10 (multiple critical
vulnerabilities)
Operational Readiness: 1/10 (no monitoring,
logging, or alerting)
SDLC & Deployment: 1.5/10 (no CI/CD, fully
manual)
Scalability Design: 2/10 (database anti-
patterns that don't scale)
This score doesn’t mean "bad engineer” — it
means “not ready for the Solutions Architect
level being hired for.”
Looking for honest feedback and transparent
hiring insights in the cloud space. What are
your biggest red flags when evaluating
architect-level candidates?
Amazon Web Services (AWS) Andy Jassy
Matt Garman Jeff Johnson Hussein Mohd
Ali Huajia Ma
#AWS #SolutionsArchitect
#CloudArchitecture #TechHiring
#AWSCloud #CloudComputing
#SoftwareEngineering #Hiringinsights
#CareerDevelopment #Recruiting
#TechRecruitment #IndonesianTech
©© 2-2.Comments
Nur Muhammad A.
Cloud—infra, DevSecOps, and Al | Bach.
ini bukannya cuma personal
project? dan juga udah lama, maybe
masih dalam tahap belajar?
S Like . © Reply
Commentary
What he posted
He posted it on LinkedIn at about 03:30 WIB on 28 May 2026. It presents a “Hiring Manager Summary” with “Candidate: Rahmat Fabhian Aminuddin”, “Assessment Standard: AWS Principal Engineer Level”, “Overall Rating: 3.2/10” and “Recommendation: DO NOT HIRE for Solutions Architect Role”, based on “Rahmat’s CV Checker project”, with scores such as “Testing & Quality Assurance: 0/10”. He tagged AWS, Andy Jassy, Matt Garman, Jeff Johnson, Hussein Mohd Ali and Huajia Ma. A commenter replied: “ini bukannya cuma personal project? dan juga udah lama, maybe masih dalam tahap belajar?” (“isn’t this just a personal project? and an old one too, maybe still at the learning stage?”)
Context
Forty minutes later he posted a second assessment of the same man with a different score, 4.2/10 (ev-20260527-009). He merged both into a “3.2-4.2/10” range in his “case study” the next day (ev-20260528-002).
Observations
A side project graded as a job application
The evaluation is of a “CV Checker project”, which a commenter points out is an old personal project. He grades it for testing, monitoring and CI/CD as if it were a production system. Few learning projects would pass that test.
A principal-level bar for a different role
He measures a candidate for a Solutions Architect role against an “AWS Principal Engineer Level” standard. That is a senior engineering level, not the role he names. Setting the bar there guarantees the low score.
No vacancy, yet a hiring verdict
No employer has asked for this evaluation and no vacancy is named. The recommendation “DO NOT HIRE” is addressed to anyone who might hire the man, and AWS’s leaders are tagged. The format of a hiring report is used to warn people off him.